The Importance of Honesty in the Attorney-Client Relationship

As an expert in the legal field, I have seen firsthand the importance of honesty in the attorney-client relationship. In fact, Section 16 of the Reformulation specifically states that an attorney must “treat the client honestly.” This means that not only is it a professional obligation, but it is also a crucial aspect of building trust and maintaining a positive working relationship with clients. When it comes to honesty, there are two key components that lawyers must adhere to: not knowingly making false statements to clients and providing all necessary information to avoid misleading them. This is essential in any relationship, but especially in the attorney-client relationship where trust and open communication are vital.

As a client, you should feel confident that your lawyer is being honest with you. In return, it is equally important for you to be completely honest with your lawyer. Lawyers often rely on their clients to provide them with information and data for use in a representation, whether it be in a legal matter or litigation. While lawyers are not required to independently verify the accuracy of this information, they are still bound by professional standards that prohibit them from knowingly making false statements about material facts or law to others.

It is important to note that honesty and truthfulness are not interchangeable terms. Being honest means not telling lies, while being truthful means actively disclosing the whole truth about a matter. As lawyers, we are expected to be honest, but we are not always required to tell the entire truth. For example, a criminal lawyer defending a client may not be obligated to actively present the truth.

While they cannot deliberately mislead the court, they also do not have an obligation to disclose their client's entire story. This is because the lawyer's primary goal is to protect their client's interests, and sometimes that may mean keeping certain information confidential. The attorney-client relationship is built on trust, which is further protected by the attorney-client privilege. This privilege prevents an attorney from being forced to disclose any communication made by a client during representation, with limited exceptions.

If this privilege is breached, not only can it harm the case, but it can also damage the relationship between the lawyer and client. In most cases, lawyers will not have a complete understanding of the events leading up to a legal matter without consulting and trusting their clients. This is why it is crucial for clients to be honest with their lawyers. It is also important for clients to do their due diligence when choosing a lawyer.

This includes talking to other clients, reading testimonials, and not settling for the first lawyer they speak to. While it is true that there are some bad lawyers out there who may not prioritize honesty, this is not representative of the legal profession as a whole. In fact, lawyers are bound by a fiduciary duty to put their clients' interests above their own. This means that they must act in their clients' best interests and maintain confidentiality.

When it comes to honesty in the legal field, it is important to understand that it is not always about determining the existence of a historical fact. Instead, it focuses on the accuracy and authenticity of the lawyer's current statements on behalf of their client. While the judicial system aims to uncover the truth, this is not always the primary goal for lawyers. As lawyers, we must navigate our dual role as both our client's defender and a court official.

This can be challenging at times, especially when faced with difficult ethical issues. In these situations, the principle of honesty can serve as a guide for lawyers to make ethical decisions. It is also important to note that lawyers do not work in isolation. We are bound by rules of professional responsibility and other guidelines that regulate our conduct.

However, these rules can only provide limited help in resolving complex issues.

Ernest Carsten
Ernest Carsten

Hardcore beer fan. Unapologetic troublemaker. Avid coffee guru. Total bacon lover. Devoted travel fanatic. Professional music buff.