The Truth About Attorney-Client Privilege: Can Lawyers Snitch on Clients?

As an expert in the legal field, I am often asked about the boundaries of attorney-client privilege and whether lawyers can report their clients. The answer is not a simple yes or no, as there are certain circumstances where a lawyer may be required to disclose confidential information. However, in general, the attorney-client privilege is a crucial rule that protects the confidentiality of communications between attorneys and clients. The attorney-client privilege ensures that exchanges between you and your lawyer remain private. This means that any information or conversation shared with your lawyer is strictly prohibited from being disclosed to any other person without the client's explicit permission.

As a client, it is important to understand that you can and must tell your lawyer the truth in order for them to effectively represent you. One common concern is whether a lawyer will betray their client or disclose confidential information if they have committed a crime. However, it is important to note that a lawyer has a duty to respect ethical standards and cannot evade this obligation simply because their client asks them to. This was emphasized in a court case where it was ruled that a lawyer cannot disclose confidential information even if their client has committed a serious crime. So, what happens if you are a good lawyer and your client did something wrong? Should you report them to the authorities? The answer is not straightforward and depends on the specific circumstances of the case. As a lawyer, my job is to ensure that my clients' constitutional rights are protected, to fight for them, and to show that the prosecutor does not have enough evidence to prove their guilt. It is important for clients to understand that lawyers want to hear everything, no matter what.

This is because a lawyer cannot defend what they do not know. However, there may be instances where an attorney will only want to hear specific facts about a case in order to avoid being limited in their defense. This is why it is crucial for clients to be completely honest with their lawyers. One issue that has been raised is the potential for companies to misuse the attorney-client privilege by directing internal problems to lawyers instead of ethics departments. This means that if you have a telephone conversation with a potential lawyer or meet at their office, but ultimately decide not to hire them, your initial consultation will still be protected by the attorney-client privilege. As a lawyer, I am bound by the Rules of Professional Conduct, which dictate that I cannot disclose any information about my client's business or matters, except in very limited and specific circumstances.

For example, if there is an imminent risk of death or serious bodily injury, I may be required to disclose confidential information in order to prevent harm. It is important to note that the rules and regulations surrounding attorney-client privilege may vary depending on the court system and state bar associations. However, one thing remains consistent: lawyers who violate the attorney-client privilege can face serious consequences. State bar associations across the country have not hesitated to punish lawyers who report their clients outside of the limited circumstances allowed by the regulations. Some may wonder about the definition of "original information" and whether it includes all information received by an internal lawyer in their capacity as an internal lawyer. While this may vary depending on the specific rules and regulations, it is generally understood that confidential information shared with an internal lawyer is still protected by the attorney-client privilege. Finally, it is important for clients to understand that even if they are technically guilty of a crime, their lawyer may still be able to obtain a reduction or dismissal of their case due to extenuating circumstances or issues of suppression.

This is why it is crucial to have a strong and trustworthy relationship with your lawyer, built on honesty and trust.

Ernest Carsten
Ernest Carsten

Hardcore beer fan. Unapologetic troublemaker. Avid coffee guru. Total bacon lover. Devoted travel fanatic. Professional music buff.